Can a housing society expel its member?
Yes, but procedure is not easy. If expelled, member loses the right to his property
Recently, a housing society in Bandra, Mumbai has sought expulsion of one of its members. The complaint against him was that he used to harass the society by filing Right To Information (RTI) applications. The Co-operative Societies Act, which also governs housing societies, allows this. But the process is not easy.
A co-operative housing society can expel members under Section 35 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. According to the Act, a member can be expelled if he/she willfully deceives the society, provides false information to the society, acts against the society’s by-laws, does not pay the society’s dues persistently or is involved in illegal or immoral activities. The co-operative societies rules are similar for other states and include similar provisions for expelling members.
However, the conditions are subjective and the society has to prove it to the Registrar of Co-operative Housing Societies. The member can challenge the order in court.
Expelling a member is a very stringent move and not something the society can follow as a matter of right, says Anshuman Jagtap, advocate with Hariani and Company.
There is a procedure to be followed for expelling members. The society has to first issue a show cause notice to the member and give him a 30-day period to respond to it. The member has to be informed of the date, time and place of the meeting. If the notice of the meeting is not given, the expulsion will be illegal. Then the society has to call a General Body Meeting. The resolution should be discussed at the meeting. The member should be given an opportunity at the meeting to defend his case. He can either do it himself or through other members.
The resolution should be passed by three-fourths majority, and not simple majority. Following this, the resolution has to be filed with the Registrar, within 30 days. The Registrar will then hear both parties-the society and the member against whom action is being taken. Within 180 days of receiving the resolution, the Registrar has to either reject it or approve it.
Sometimes the society uses expulsion as a threat to ensure that members pay up pending dues, especially if the member is not available, says Jagtap. In case of expulsion, the member has to forfeit the shares of the society, in other words the right to the property. Then the society gets the right of the property. But in cities like Mumbai, where the value of the property can run into crores, it is unlikely that members will give up the property, says Anil Harish, of D M Harish and Advocates. “In such cases the member goes to court and the litigation could go on for a long time. But in case of an agricultural society, where the member has, say an acre of land, he may give up the property if expelled,” he says. As an informal way out, the society may tell the member to sell his flat and leave, Harish adds.
Expulsion on grounds of religion is also not permitted according to law. In such case even if the society amends its by-laws, the Registrar will not agree, Jagtap adds.
Consumer activist Jehangir Gai says a member can be expelled if he causes damage to the structure of the building or structurally weakens the building by carrying out illegal repairs or renovation in his flat. But expelling a member for RTI is unlikely to be approved since that is his right. At the same time, the society is not bound to respond to the RTI, since it is not a public authority.
A co-operative housing society can expel members under Section 35 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. According to the Act, a member can be expelled if he/she willfully deceives the society, provides false information to the society, acts against the society’s by-laws, does not pay the society’s dues persistently or is involved in illegal or immoral activities. The co-operative societies rules are similar for other states and include similar provisions for expelling members.
However, the conditions are subjective and the society has to prove it to the Registrar of Co-operative Housing Societies. The member can challenge the order in court.
Expelling a member is a very stringent move and not something the society can follow as a matter of right, says Anshuman Jagtap, advocate with Hariani and Company.
There is a procedure to be followed for expelling members. The society has to first issue a show cause notice to the member and give him a 30-day period to respond to it. The member has to be informed of the date, time and place of the meeting. If the notice of the meeting is not given, the expulsion will be illegal. Then the society has to call a General Body Meeting. The resolution should be discussed at the meeting. The member should be given an opportunity at the meeting to defend his case. He can either do it himself or through other members.
The resolution should be passed by three-fourths majority, and not simple majority. Following this, the resolution has to be filed with the Registrar, within 30 days. The Registrar will then hear both parties-the society and the member against whom action is being taken. Within 180 days of receiving the resolution, the Registrar has to either reject it or approve it.
Sometimes the society uses expulsion as a threat to ensure that members pay up pending dues, especially if the member is not available, says Jagtap. In case of expulsion, the member has to forfeit the shares of the society, in other words the right to the property. Then the society gets the right of the property. But in cities like Mumbai, where the value of the property can run into crores, it is unlikely that members will give up the property, says Anil Harish, of D M Harish and Advocates. “In such cases the member goes to court and the litigation could go on for a long time. But in case of an agricultural society, where the member has, say an acre of land, he may give up the property if expelled,” he says. As an informal way out, the society may tell the member to sell his flat and leave, Harish adds.
Expulsion on grounds of religion is also not permitted according to law. In such case even if the society amends its by-laws, the Registrar will not agree, Jagtap adds.
Consumer activist Jehangir Gai says a member can be expelled if he causes damage to the structure of the building or structurally weakens the building by carrying out illegal repairs or renovation in his flat. But expelling a member for RTI is unlikely to be approved since that is his right. At the same time, the society is not bound to respond to the RTI, since it is not a public authority.
There are Co-operative Housing Societies which threat members with Expulsion, just because some of the members informed the Govt Authorities about Society`s ongoing illegal work, through which Society received demolition notices from Municipality.Collectively members enjoy the fruit of illegal and un-authorised work collectively.Then the genuine person who informed to govt can be harassed. What are the remedies to aggrieved members, if the Secretary is threatening them with expulsion out of personal enemity?
ReplyDelete